Episode 226

full
Published on:

16th Nov 2026

Jimmy Movie History: Fact vs. Fiction | History for Your Road Trip

Try the "History or Drive" history travel app

Jimmy movie history, examined by a historian: what does the film get right, and where does Hollywood take liberties?

Scott and Jenn compare the movie with the real events and people behind it, bringing their light-hearted History vs. Hollywood conversation to Talk With History. Great history for your road trip to Hollywood to visit Jimmy Stewart's gravesite...or his hometown in Indiana, Pennsylvania.

Watch the companion video for more historical context.

-------------------------------------------------------

🗺️ Want to visit the places we talked about? We've mapped them all (and more) in History or Drive. 🗺️

🚗 Download our History or Drive travel app

Turn your next road trip into an American history adventure.

Discover hidden local history, epic historic sites, battlefields, and maps with easy, one-click driving directions — history and travel right in the palm of your hand!

-------------------------------------------------------

🎙️ Talk with History is the #1 Road Trip podcast for History Travelers!

⭐ Enjoying the journey? Leave us a quick review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify to help other history and travel lovers find the show!

-------------------------------------------------------

Transcript
Speaker:

Before he was America's favorite everyman on the silver screen, Jimmy Stewart was

Speaker:

a tall, soft-spoken kid from Pennsylvania who loved two things: building

Speaker:

model airplanes and telling stories.

Speaker:

By 1941, he had reached the absolute pinnacle of Hollywood, winning an

Speaker:

Academy Award for The Philadelphia Story.

Speaker:

He had fame, fortune, and the studio system at his feet.

Speaker:

Yet, nine months before Pearl Harbor, Stewart walked away from it all, refusing

Speaker:

to stay stateside, making propaganda films after being drafted to the US Army.

Speaker:

Instead, he fought to fly in combat, eventually leading 20 harrowing bombing

Speaker:

missions over Nazi-occupied Germany.

Speaker:

When he returned to Hollywood after the war, the boyish charm was gone, replaced

Speaker:

by a raw, haunting vulnerability forged in the flak-filled skies over Europe.

Speaker:

Without the trauma and the sacrifice, we would never have gotten the

Speaker:

unforgettable and gut-wrenching performance that became George Bailey.

Speaker:

Now, with the brand-new biopic Jimmy hitting the theaters, the extraordinary

Speaker:

courage and service of Jimmy Stewart, the man who brought us It's a Wonderful

Speaker:

Life, is finally taking center stage.

Speaker:

Welcome to Talk with History.

Speaker:

One filmmaker, one historian, leading history-inspired world

Speaker:

travels for the curious, the history lovers, and the explorer in us all.

Speaker:

I'm your host, Scott, here with my wife and historian, Jenn.

Speaker:

Hello.

Speaker:

Today, we're diving into the brand-new film, Jimmy, exploring the remarkable

Speaker:

life, career, and wartime sacrifice of Hollywood legend James Stewart.

Speaker:

We're breaking down what the new movie gets right, tracing his journey from

Speaker:

an Oscar-winning leading man to a decorated B-24 bomber pilot in World War

Speaker:

II, and looking how the real weight of combat permanently changed his acting.

Speaker:

We'll also talk about why films like It's a Wonderful Life hit so differently when

Speaker:

you understand the real-life battle scars Stewart brought back to the set in 1946.

Speaker:

I'm Scott Benne.

Speaker:

So dim the theater lights and check your instruments.

Speaker:

We're exploring the extraordinary true story of Jimmy Stewart.

Speaker:

All right, Jenn, so This is kind of like a Watch With History episode.

Speaker:

We do these every now and then about movies, movie reviews.

Speaker:

Not really a review so much as like, "Hey, what's the history behind this?" Yeah.

Speaker:

Like, what's accurate?

Speaker:

We did it with Young Washington.

Speaker:

Now, this is something that you've been anticipating for quite some

Speaker:

time, um, and that is the movie Jimmy.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

About James Maitland Stewart, uh, an actor in your favorite movie of

Speaker:

all time, It's a Wonderful Life.

Speaker:

So for those who come in to watch this video, we're gonna

Speaker:

talk about kinda what was true.

Speaker:

A lot of people didn't know how much he served and how long he served, and some

Speaker:

of the things that Hollywood compresses.

Speaker:

We talked a little bit about it, you and I, as we were walking out of the

Speaker:

theater when we saw it the other day.

Speaker:

So, so tell, tell me, tell the audience a little bit about Jimmy Stewart and this

Speaker:

movie that we're about to talk about.

Speaker:

So this movie is about the highest-ranking military officer

Speaker:

actor of all time, in Jimmy Stewart.

Speaker:

And the thing is, like, that's not a surprise to our channel and our viewers.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

We've celebrated this about Jimmy Stewart for a while now because he

Speaker:

is in my favorite movie of all time.

Speaker:

I think it was, like, our fourth video ever.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

We go to his hometown.

Speaker:

We, we go to his hometown and do his museum.

Speaker:

I'll link to it.

Speaker:

And we s- I stand on his front porch.

Speaker:

Like, his, his parents no longer… You know, it's not his family house anymore.

Speaker:

But, uh, I… You know, and they probably don't want people on their front porch.

Speaker:

I jumped on it real fast and jun- jumped off.

Speaker:

Uh, and there are some people who knew about him, but I feel like this

Speaker:

movie's gonna make it so much bigger.

Speaker:

He lived on, uh, the top of a hill overlooking Indiana.

Speaker:

There was a little placard about him there.

Speaker:

The crosswalks there had his voice.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

We're gonna talk more about some of the pictures that were taken of him there

Speaker:

after he returns home from World War II.

Speaker:

Uh, but they have an entire museum to him, him there.

Speaker:

So we have two videos a- about that.

Speaker:

And h- the Oscar, at the end of the movie you see him win a lifetime

Speaker:

achievement Oscar, 'cause he only wins, receives two Oscars in his lifetime,

Speaker:

the first for Philadelphia Story, which you see in the beginning before he's

Speaker:

even in military service, and then he gets a lifetime achievement Oscar.

Speaker:

So that museum has the lifetime achievement Oscar.

Speaker:

So it was super cool to see that as well.

Speaker:

But he's no… The story was no surprise to us, right?

Speaker:

We've been to his grave in Los Angeles, and we've just honored Jimmy

Speaker:

Stewart in a lot of different ways.

Speaker:

And not, so much so not a surprise to me, at one point Turner Classic Movies was

Speaker:

gonna have veterans on for Veterans Day, and we were supposed to pick our best

Speaker:

movies that represented Veterans Day to us, and I chose It's a Wonderful Life.

Speaker:

And most people are like, "But that's a Christmas movie." And I'm like, "No,

Speaker:

if you know the story behind it," and Jimmy Stewart just coming back from

Speaker:

military service, and he's not even playing the war hero in that movie.

Speaker:

His brother is.

Speaker:

But he is actually the, the man who supports everyone and

Speaker:

keeps ev- everything going.

Speaker:

Um, that is a Veterans Day movie.

Speaker:

And so I think this biography did a very good job of Connecting all of that that

Speaker:

we've already loved and, and championed about Jimmy Stewart, uh, for the public

Speaker:

to just make them more aware of it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, so let's kinda go through this, 'cause you covered a whole lot there.

Speaker:

Because we've talked about him a whole lot, and we've done … We've

Speaker:

been to his grave, we've been to his hometown, we've talked about, you

Speaker:

know, him in other videos in the past.

Speaker:

So we've, we've done a lot, and you can speak very easily

Speaker:

to all things Jimmy Stewart.

Speaker:

So he grew up in Indiana, Pennsylvania.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Interesting fact about Indiana, Pennsylvania, it's considered the

Speaker:

Christmas tree capital of the world.

Speaker:

And so if people don't know that, you are welcome.

Speaker:

Right?

Speaker:

You now have a, a fun little f- uh, a fun fact for your next Christmas party

Speaker:

is ask somebody what the Christmas tree capital of the world, and you can

Speaker:

tell them it is Indiana, Pennsylvania, which is the hometown of Jimmy Stewart.

Speaker:

Not far from Pittsburgh, but not easy to get to either.

Speaker:

It's not along any major highways.

Speaker:

So it's one of those we had to take the back roads to get to it.

Speaker:

But it's a cute little town, and, uh, and he grew up there.

Speaker:

And the same s- house that he, he wasn't born in, but he was brought

Speaker:

there right as a young child.

Speaker:

He lived there.

Speaker:

That's the house he comes back to after the war.

Speaker:

He doesn't really have a place of his own, so that's where he comes back on leave.

Speaker:

And, and you've seen, if you're watching this, and I'll put some of

Speaker:

the, the pictures up on screen, you've probably seen some of these pictures

Speaker:

that I'm putting up on screen of him in his uniform in his father's hardware

Speaker:

store, basically on the main street there in, in Indiana, Indiana, PA.

Speaker:

So let's kinda go through the life of Jimmy Stewart, right?

Speaker:

As he comes into Hollywood, and really the movie starts where

Speaker:

most people know him, right?

Speaker:

Which is kind of where we'll start, kinda where the movie starts, and that

Speaker:

is he just won an Oscar in 1940- 1941.

Speaker:

1940. 1940. Um, wh- the movie he made in 1940.

Speaker:

Um, so he won for The Philadelphia Story.

Speaker:

So Jimmy Stewart is from a s- you know, small town, Indiana, PA. His

Speaker:

father owns this hardware store.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Which was his grandfather's hardware store.

Speaker:

Um, J.M. Stewart & Company Hardware Store.

Speaker:

Today it's a bank.

Speaker:

It's right across from the Jimmy Stewart Museum, and they

Speaker:

have pictures of it there.

Speaker:

So it was like a family legacy.

Speaker:

His father pretty much assumed he would run this hardware store.

Speaker:

But when he went to Princeton, so Jimmy Stewart's a pretty smart kid.

Speaker:

He goes to Princeton for school.

Speaker:

He gets bit by the acting bug there.

Speaker:

He meets Henry Fonda, right?

Speaker:

They start doing acting and running around and doing these shows, and he

Speaker:

and Henry Fonda move out to, uh, LA together to try their hand at Hollywood.

Speaker:

So his father still thinks, "Okay, after he does this thing, he'll come

Speaker:

back home and run the hardware store." So the funny thing about that is he

Speaker:

wins an Oscar, and he's, in the movie it's depicted that he's had a party

Speaker:

all night and he's sleeping, and his dad calls and he answers the phone.

Speaker:

In reality- Jimmy called his father and, uh, his dad said, "I heard you

Speaker:

won some award or plaque or something.

Speaker:

Might as well send it home and I'll put it in the front store window." And that

Speaker:

is what happens to Jimmy Stewart's Oscar.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And there are pictures of that, and it was in there for, like, 40 years.

Speaker:

It just stood in the front window.

Speaker:

But his dad, at the same time, is still kind of regarding this

Speaker:

acting career as just something he needs to get out of his system.

Speaker:

A- and they do that … And they show that in the movie a little bit.

Speaker:

And then he'll come home and run the hardware store.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But … And in The Philadelphia Story and in a lot of these early movies

Speaker:

that Jimmy Stewart's doing, and some do well and some don't, he definitely

Speaker:

plays, like, this novice, new-to-life man who's f- small town, learning

Speaker:

everything, and The Philadelphia Story is very much like that, right?

Speaker:

And so- What I think the big transition is what war does to Jimmy Stewart, and

Speaker:

what war does to his acting career, and the choices he makes, and how he

Speaker:

can portray, uh, a person on screen.

Speaker:

So that's kinda what it's showing.

Speaker:

But they also depict, and this is same in the museum, is he comes

Speaker:

from a long line of veterans.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

So people who have served their country.

Speaker:

And, and they show this in the movie.

Speaker:

It, you know, very much in the movie it kind of becomes a almost like a

Speaker:

f- interesting friction point, and that was one of the things that I

Speaker:

kinda mentally noted is in the movie at one point he kinda went home and

Speaker:

visited his father, and his father was talking to him about military service.

Speaker:

I think it was supposedly after he was drafted.

Speaker:

They, they compress some things in the movie.

Speaker:

And- And I didn't know if that friction was actually there between him and his

Speaker:

father like they showed in the movie.

Speaker:

So no.

Speaker:

Jimmy Stewart always will say he had a very loving relationship with

Speaker:

his father, although his father was not one to say, "I love you."

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

His father was one to show his care by putting his Oscar in the window,

Speaker:

or mentoring him, or telling him life stories, or just taking care of

Speaker:

him, or calling him often, or saving his bedroom for him to come home.

Speaker:

Like, those kind of taking care of his life k- type of things

Speaker:

is how he showed his love.

Speaker:

But it wasn't that awkwardness they kind of show.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And Jimmy Stewart didn't need to be reminded of his military legacy.

Speaker:

He was very aware of these f- his father served in the Spanish-American War and

Speaker:

World War I, and then he had relatives who served in Revolutionary War and

Speaker:

Civil War, and he was aware of that.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And he was proud of that.

Speaker:

And, and it was interesting 'cause that's what I, I noted in the movie.

Speaker:

They made it look like he was kind of torn between trying to stay in Hollywood.

Speaker:

So in the movie, right, if you haven't seen it yet,

Speaker:

there's n- really no spoilers.

Speaker:

This is Jimmy Stewart's life.

Speaker:

In the movie he got his draft notice, like number 311 or something like

Speaker:

that, so pretty, pretty low number.

Speaker:

So he gets drafted, and the studio's saying, "Oh, you know, one phone

Speaker:

call and I can make that go away, and you can stick around here and make

Speaker:

propaganda films," and stuff like that.

Speaker:

And it makes it look like he actually kind of initially took, he kinda took

Speaker:

that offer, and then he, he ran off home 'cause the media caught wind

Speaker:

of it, and it was like a big kinda semi-scandal, at least in the movie.

Speaker:

And he was kinda, they show this conflict of like, "Oh, maybe I should

Speaker:

go and serve," and stuff like that.

Speaker:

But I, my impression of Jimmy Stewart was like he, he won his

Speaker:

Oscar and, and not long after that he went and, and just enlisted.

Speaker:

Now I, he was drafted But I th- I, I always had the impression he went

Speaker:

willingly, and he actually had to go back, 'cause didn't he enlist

Speaker:

one time and he was too skinny?

Speaker:

So he went, put on a bunch of… Well, not a bunch of weight, but enough

Speaker:

weight so that he wasn't too, too, uh, light for his, how tall he was.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Then he re-enlisted.

Speaker:

So he, he wanted to serve.

Speaker:

Like, they initially told him, "No, you're basically too tall and

Speaker:

skinny." He went, put some weight on, came back and said, "Sign me up."

Speaker:

So yeah.

Speaker:

They, and they kind of, they mention that in the movie.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

The real conflict would have been that Louis B. Mayer wanted him not to

Speaker:

serve- The head of the studio … the head of the studio of, um, MGM,

Speaker:

who he has his contract with.

Speaker:

'Cause this is the time when you would be a contracted actor with a

Speaker:

studio, and he was contracted with MGM, and that is who made him a star.

Speaker:

Uh, and so the conflict was Jimmy Stewart wanted to serve.

Speaker:

It wasn't any question, and he wanted to serve in the real military.

Speaker:

Louis B. Mayer wanted him to serve, uh, in the Hollywood military, make propaganda

Speaker:

movies or stay stateside or- And there was actors that did that … and,

Speaker:

or we can help this kinda go away.

Speaker:

And that would've been more of the conflict, because Jimmy

Speaker:

Stewart did not want to do that.

Speaker:

He wanted to serve his country in a real capacity, and he wanted to be an aviator.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And if you go to the museum and, or see his boyhood home, and they allude to it

Speaker:

with the, the mobile with the planes, he was a huge Charles Lindbergh fan.

Speaker:

And there was Charles Lindbergh models and things all over his bedroom,

Speaker:

which is ironic, 'cause he's gonna play Charles Lindbergh later in life.

Speaker:

Oh, yeah, that's right.

Speaker:

Uh, so he always wanted to be an aviator, and he d- had a private pilot's license.

Speaker:

So that was where he wanted to serve, and that's why he takes it

Speaker:

upon himself to join the military with his own capacity to be a pilot.

Speaker:

Uh, so the, the conflict wasn't whether or not he should serve.

Speaker:

The conflict was more, "I want to really serve." And that would've been a more

Speaker:

realistic conversation he would've had with Louis B. Mayer than, uh, "I'm

Speaker:

not sure, sir, if I even wanna serve." But they do a lot of these little

Speaker:

anecdotal things in the movie that really allude to It's a Wonderful Life.

Speaker:

Yeah, they do that a lot.

Speaker:

So he sits in this chair that's a lot lower than how Louis B. Mayer sits.

Speaker:

Now, I don't know if that was true, but that's true in It's a Wonderful Life-

Speaker:

Yeah … when he meets Mr. Potter.

Speaker:

Yeah, he's sitting in the chair, and he's, like, way down here-

Speaker:

Mm-hmm … and Mr. Potter's way up there.

Speaker:

Um- And you know Jimmy Stewart to be a tall man anyway, so to make him

Speaker:

to look even smaller, uh, tries to give that power image, and that's

Speaker:

happens in It's a Wonderful Life.

Speaker:

So- I think they were trying to s- show how it really mimics, like

Speaker:

his real life mimicked that movie.

Speaker:

Uh, I don't think that really happened.

Speaker:

And I had read one review that's like, "Even if you didn't know

Speaker:

things about Jimmy Stewart, this movie's gonna ram him down your

Speaker:

throat." And there was a lot of that.

Speaker:

Like- It- … if you didn't know, they're gonna make sure you know it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, so he was initially drafted and rejected for

Speaker:

enlistment in October of 1940.

Speaker:

Then he came, he went, put on some weight- Mm-hmm … came back in March of 1941.

Speaker:

So remember, if you didn't know this, this is pre-Pearl Harbor.

Speaker:

America hadn't really been pulled into the war yet.

Speaker:

So that's one of the things when I learned this about Jimmy Stewart, that

Speaker:

I, that k- as soon as I learned that, I kinda had a little bit more respect,

Speaker:

I guess, is one way to kinda put it, or, or just kinda, just kind of put

Speaker:

him in higher esteem, um, is that he's trying to do this before Pearl Harbor,

Speaker:

Harbor happened, and then obviously everybody was off to war after that.

Speaker:

So in March of 1941, that's when he c- he comes back.

Speaker:

He's heavy ev- heavy enough now.

Speaker:

They let him enlist, and then he basically works his way to be a pilot- Mm-hmm

Speaker:

… and he becomes a B-24, uh, pilot.

Speaker:

Yep, Liberator pilot.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Now, it's interesting in the movie, they have, uh, Ginger Rogers and him

Speaker:

having a little, uh, you know, love affair and stuff, and that is all true.

Speaker:

So when you're hired by the studio, much like, uh, Jimmy Stewart was, MGM, they

Speaker:

really, like, modeled your private life, and they… You see the reporter meeting

Speaker:

him, and what, what are they gonna print?

Speaker:

And the studio makes a very big interest that they, they take a very

Speaker:

big interest in modeling your l- personal life for the tabloids, right?

Speaker:

So people know all these things about you.

Speaker:

So that relationship with Ginger Rogers, although real, and although he's

Speaker:

going out to the Hollywood nightclubs and stuff, it wasn't substantial.

Speaker:

It wasn't like a real relationship, and that's why it was kinda so easy

Speaker:

for him to say goodbye and, and go.

Speaker:

But I love how they have all the kiss marks on the handkerchief, and we're

Speaker:

gonna talk about that later- Yeah

Speaker:

and who they were, and the famous actresses they were.

Speaker:

Uh, if you go to his museum today, he did go out to those nightclubs in the

Speaker:

evening, and he had a special booth in one of them, and they have one

Speaker:

of those booths there at the museum.

Speaker:

So this is the day of the Brown Derby and these different Hollywood nightclubs

Speaker:

where people wanted to be seen and be s- seen, uh, see and be seen, to go into

Speaker:

the tabloids, to be a star so people could read about you in the magazines

Speaker:

and imagine your life and make it bigger than life, and that's, th- it's all

Speaker:

constructed by the studios at the time.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So now he- He enlists, uh, kind of, he, I think, did he already have,

Speaker:

like, a private pilot's license?

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

Is that how he kinda, they, they basically moved him from being a private

Speaker:

all the way up to being an officer because they said, "Hey, you've got a

Speaker:

private pilot's license." And college.

Speaker:

And college, right?

Speaker:

So they move him off to be an officer.

Speaker:

So he's, but he's training up for, like, a good year or two, right?

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

And he, yeah, he's training up for a good year or two, all Stateside, but, uh, he's

Speaker:

been really pushing to go into theater.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And to go over to Europe, 'cause they do wanna, they do wanna protect him,

Speaker:

because the, the military is very aware of what bad publicity it would be if

Speaker:

Jimmy Stewart was killed in an accident.

Speaker:

And, and they did use him, and I'll show it up.

Speaker:

Um, I'll, I'll play a clip right here.

Speaker:

Gee, looks like I'm back in the movies again, don't I?

Speaker:

Well, as a matter of fact, I'd like to do some talking.

Speaker:

Thad

Speaker:

Don't go away until I get this thing off What you just saw, and what I

Speaker:

just played the audio of, is a clip of him kind of doing a promotional,

Speaker:

like, a, I think it's called Win Your Wings or something like that- Mm-hmm

Speaker:

a video for the Army Air Corps.

Speaker:

So he did do some of that, but like you said, and they show this in the

Speaker:

movie, and he's reporting to his colonel, who's Rob Riggle, who's

Speaker:

actually former Marine i- in real life.

Speaker:

But, uh, he's reporting to him saying, you know, "Don't I deserve to, to be out

Speaker:

there on, essentially on the front line, you know, just, just like everybody else?"

Speaker:

And there's, there's kind of a bunch of pushback, but he eventually

Speaker:

kinda works his way in, and he starts flying combat missions.

Speaker:

Yeah, it was called Winning Your Wings- Yeah … and it helped recruit airmen.

Speaker:

And it was actually nominated for an Academy Award for

Speaker:

Best Documentary in 1942.

Speaker:

Really?

Speaker:

Uh, and it appeared in, uh, movie theaters nationwide, and it, uh,

Speaker:

resulted in 150,000 new recruits.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So it was successful, but that's not what he wanted to do.

Speaker:

Uh, he wanted to get out there.

Speaker:

Um, he trained pilots, uh, for a while in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and that's

Speaker:

when he appeals to his commander in November of 1943, and you will see that

Speaker:

in the movie, uh, to be part of the s- uh, 703rd Bomb Squadron in England.

Speaker:

And finally, he, he gets promoted and he is allowed to go and do that.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Now, in the movie, they show him kinda doing his trip.

Speaker:

He's leading his, I guess his squadron of B-24s on a flight

Speaker:

basically kind of across the Atlantic.

Speaker:

They're making their way up to England.

Speaker:

And on their way, I think w- like, there's a plane, maybe two, that are

Speaker:

shot down by German ships- Mm-hmm

Speaker:

on, on the way out.

Speaker:

And so one of the things that I looked up when I was kinda saying, "Hey,

Speaker:

is this fact or fiction? Would they really leave an aircraft behind?" And

Speaker:

at the time, that was actually true.

Speaker:

Part of their protocol was not to turn around and continue to make other

Speaker:

aircraft more vulnerable by coming, by coming back around to try to pick

Speaker:

these guys up or at least annotate, you know, mark where they were until another

Speaker:

Navy ship could come and pick them up.

Speaker:

Um, so that was something that they show right away.

Speaker:

As soon as he's flying out to England, they show the things

Speaker:

that he's going through.

Speaker:

So it's true that military would do that.

Speaker:

It's not true that it actually happened to Jimmy Stewart.

Speaker:

Oh, really?

Speaker:

So that's the issue, yes.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

Uh, it didn't happen on his flyover to England, but it is true that

Speaker:

that would happen, and Jimmy Stewart would hear those stories.

Speaker:

So you would still hear those stories about ai- that happening to your fellow

Speaker:

airmen, but it wasn't his decision.

Speaker:

It wasn't his call.

Speaker:

It didn't happen to the people with him.

Speaker:

But again, this is a movie, so they want you to, to feel all the things

Speaker:

that could be experienced by a soldier to result in the post-traumatic

Speaker:

stress that he's gonna bring home with him from this, uh, deployment.

Speaker:

Yeah, so he starts, he starts flying missions.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

And they very clearly show, like, he's- Just like all the other pilots

Speaker:

and all the other airmen that were up there, uh, kinda dropping bombs over

Speaker:

Germany and all the different spots, he, I mean, he starts losing men.

Speaker:

He, again, he's, he's a captain, I think, and so he is at the time, is that right?

Speaker:

He's promoted to major in- Me?

Speaker:

Okay … in January of 1944, and then he'll make colonel in March of 1945.

Speaker:

Uh, what's interesting is he is one of the few Americans to ever rise

Speaker:

from private to colonel in four years.

Speaker:

Oh, I didn't know that.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

But they, but they do show, I think before he gets promoted to

Speaker:

colonel, they kinda show he…

Speaker:

And they talk about this very early on, this is kind of well-known.

Speaker:

He, he ends up flying 20 combat missions, and- Mm-hmm … throughout these

Speaker:

combat missions, he's losing aircraft.

Speaker:

His aircraft gets shot up, and he has guys in his aircraft that get

Speaker:

hit with either flak or bullets or whatever that is, and they're starting

Speaker:

to show kind of all the things that Jimmy Stewart is going through.

Speaker:

And the thing, and, and this is just Scott Bennie's opinion here, I

Speaker:

thought they, they were, they were laying it on pretty thick, right?

Speaker:

That was the one thing that I will say about this.

Speaker:

They were laying it on pretty thick on how he's trying to inspire his men to

Speaker:

kinda continue to go up there and fly.

Speaker:

I don't know how much pushback.

Speaker:

Like, one of the scenes they were showing, like, he's starting to brief a mission,

Speaker:

and there's, you know, his airmen in the, kinda sitting there in the briefing

Speaker:

kind of basically start saying like, "Well, they don't care about us over

Speaker:

there, and they don't care if we live or die," and this, that, and the other.

Speaker:

And he has to, like, inspire them to go up, go up, go up there and fly.

Speaker:

That was a little heavy-handed to me- Yeah … just, just personally.

Speaker:

I thought that the actor did a, did a good job, but, um, I, I don't know how

Speaker:

true to life that really would've been.

Speaker:

So there's a couple things to unpack here.

Speaker:

Uh, first off, yes, would Jimmy Stewart be briefing missions?

Speaker:

Absolutely.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Because although he does fly 20 missions, all most of his time in

Speaker:

Germany is more of a deputy commander, commander of the squadron level.

Speaker:

He's not just a regular rogue pilot who's flying these missions.

Speaker:

He's in charge of the squadron.

Speaker:

So yes, would your XO sometimes fly on a mission?

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Would your XO sometimes go out and do this?

Speaker:

Yes, but it's not like you have a crew and are regularly flying.

Speaker:

So they show him with a crew- Yeah, he even co- … and flying all the

Speaker:

time … he even comments that at one point in time, like, his, his crew flew

Speaker:

without him one time, and they kinda actually show him, like, "Oh, sorry,

Speaker:

scheduling got messed up, and, um, you know, won't, won't happen again," right?

Speaker:

He's kinda joking with his crew 'cause they show him, him kind of

Speaker:

ingratiating himself with the men and kinda showing that, that brotherhood-

Speaker:

Yeah … that co- camaraderie.

Speaker:

Um- So if you're in a, if you're m- military and in a squadron, you know there

Speaker:

are your first lieutenants, your captains who are doing all of your flying, and then

Speaker:

it's your, uh, lieutenant colonels, your colonels, who are your XOs and your COs,

Speaker:

who do fly from time to time, but they're mostly briefing you on your missions.

Speaker:

And so that would be true.

Speaker:

He's going out briefing a mission.

Speaker:

Now, the thing that got me in that whole part is- The guys were upset

Speaker:

because nobody cares about them, and A, that couldn't be farther

Speaker:

from the truth the way America felt about Americans out there fighting.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And B, he uses his acting to say, "Well, that's true.

Speaker:

They don't care about you.

Speaker:

And isn't that so great that America doesn't care, and you are just, like,

Speaker:

doing this for everybody, and they don't care?" And I'm like, "Wait, I think

Speaker:

you're missing the mark here." Yeah.

Speaker:

It's not that they don't care, it's that they may not know your name.

Speaker:

They may not know who individually you are because you represent the boy next door.

Speaker:

You represent the guy down the street.

Speaker:

You rep- exact- what It's a Wonderful Life is basically about.

Speaker:

And if think they would've said that a little bit better than how

Speaker:

they said it in, in the movie, I was like, it's missing its mark.

Speaker:

But it's showing you that Jimmy Stewart is kind of using his acting and the way

Speaker:

he can kind of motivate people by who he is to help inspire the people to fly.

Speaker:

Now, I think another thing it did that I don't think it's actually

Speaker:

true is that Jimmy Stewart may not have believed what he said, and I

Speaker:

don't think that was true at all.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

It, it was… It… I, I think they were just trying to… They were

Speaker:

trying to be really, really clear in showing this internal conflict,

Speaker:

whether that was true or not.

Speaker:

And, and that's the thing is I, I don't know how Jimmy Stewart felt.

Speaker:

I can't say if that's fact or fiction.

Speaker:

Um, but they were trying to… And, and again, that almost a little,

Speaker:

little heavy-handed, uh, trying to show this internal conflict.

Speaker:

And even in his relationship- Mm-hmm … with the, with the,

Speaker:

the English gal, um, they…

Speaker:

It was- They were trying to really show, and they even, this was, I thought was

Speaker:

kinda neat, like, in an emotional scene between him and this girl he started

Speaker:

dating, right, this, this woman he started dating while he was over there in England.

Speaker:

Um, he was kind of, he's already starting to suffer from PTSD, and he

Speaker:

kinda grabs her by the shoulders, you know, in an emotional moment, just

Speaker:

like he did in the scene from It's a Wonderful Life with Mary, right, and when

Speaker:

he's at the bottom of stairs and they kinda, just before they started dating.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

Um, so they're showing those parallels of his experiences in combat and over,

Speaker:

in the war that he brought back home to Hollywood when he finally came back.

Speaker:

And he doesn't really have a relationship with a woman like that,

Speaker:

not one long-term relationship.

Speaker:

He does have a couple relationships overseas.

Speaker:

He dates and stuff, but they were just showing, again, like Scott

Speaker:

said, you know, movies give you a character so you can see this, uh,

Speaker:

this de- this arc of his development.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And so that's what she stood in for.

Speaker:

I loved the part.

Speaker:

I loved it when he was with his men, and he pulls the handkerchief, and

Speaker:

it has the kiss marks from Ginger Rogers and Olivia de Havilland

Speaker:

and Rita Wils- uh, Rita Hayworth.

Speaker:

And the guys are just so amazed, and they wanna look at it and hold it.

Speaker:

To me, I felt like that's probably more of what Jimmy Stewart did over

Speaker:

there because that was what the men wanted to see and, and hear and love,

Speaker:

especially those starlets at the time.

Speaker:

We talk about World War II and the pin-up and nose art, and that's what

Speaker:

these women represented at the time.

Speaker:

So having that handkerchief with those kiss marks, that was probably one of

Speaker:

my favorite scenes in the entire movie.

Speaker:

It, then, then they start asking him, like, "Hey, is it true that you were

Speaker:

dating Ginger Rogers?" He's, he's like, "Yeah," and then he pulls this

Speaker:

handkerchief out that has all these kiss marks on it because the actresses

Speaker:

saw him off as he was going off to war.

Speaker:

It was this public thing And so they showed that, and that was

Speaker:

really cool because that is 100% something that would happen.

Speaker:

Like, if there was a famous actor that, that had that, and he goes over, you

Speaker:

guaran-damn-tee that wh- whatever soldiers or sailors is, are working for this actor,

Speaker:

they would be like, "So is it true?"

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

You know?

Speaker:

And, uh, and so that was, that was really cool, and that was… There was moments

Speaker:

throughout this movie that I think they really nailed, and that was one of them.

Speaker:

That was one of them.

Speaker:

And there were parts that we thought were drawn out.

Speaker:

Like, uh, there was a lot with that, uh, other, the female

Speaker:

British, uh, love interest.

Speaker:

We could have gotten it with one or two scenes, and they gave us, like, eight.

Speaker:

And I was like, "Okay, we can, we understand what's happening

Speaker:

here." So those things got a little heavy-handed and long.

Speaker:

Uh, and then he comes home.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So he's doing his missions, and he comes home.

Speaker:

And, uh, and it's about him acclimating back into life.

Speaker:

D- w- and one thing that we asked about, I don't know if you had a

Speaker:

chance to look it up, one thing they show in the movie, like right after

Speaker:

he came home, his hometown kinda had this, this welcome ceremony for him.

Speaker:

And, and so that, so that wasn't true.

Speaker:

Wasn't true.

Speaker:

Because it, in the movie, it was, like, him there with his father,

Speaker:

and his father's in his World War I uniform, and he's there.

Speaker:

And you can still, he's still kinda out of it.

Speaker:

He's still processing everything as he's coming back, in the movie anyways.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

And, uh, they ask him to stand up and say something, and he just

Speaker:

can't, so his father steps in.

Speaker:

So that never happened.

Speaker:

So I think the movie was trying to show, like, severity of PTSD.

Speaker:

Now, Jimmy Stewart did have PTSD- Yep … but it wasn't to the severity where he

Speaker:

couldn't speak and he couldn't perform.

Speaker:

So- He does come home September of 1945.

Speaker:

Life Magazine will do a whole photo shoot of him from Indiana, PA. Yeah.

Speaker:

He is on the cover.

Speaker:

And- And that's those photos that I was mentioning earlier

Speaker:

and what's great about that is it has the, the town hall of Indiana,

Speaker:

which is very, uh, it looks unique, so you can tell that's what it is.

Speaker:

But there's pictures of him in front of the, uh, movie theater there.

Speaker:

There's pictures of him walking around, and that's the f- there's

Speaker:

some famous pictures of him in his dad's hardware store sitting with

Speaker:

his legs up in his military uniform.

Speaker:

And so they never did a welcome home fair.

Speaker:

He didn't want any fanfare.

Speaker:

And really, the first time the city of Indiana has a big fair for him, he's

Speaker:

in his 70s when they open the museum.

Speaker:

Oh, wow.

Speaker:

So there's nothing like that.

Speaker:

But I think, again, movie-isms.

Speaker:

They wanna show he is welcomed home by his hometown.

Speaker:

Uh, and it's Veterans Day, and so people in their uniform, but he's having

Speaker:

a hard time just coming back home.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I mean, they do show that he didn't want the spotlight because of his

Speaker:

service, because at, at, uh, when he comes back from the war in the movie, he

Speaker:

talks to the head of the studio again.

Speaker:

The head of the studio said, kinda gives him the typical Hollywood

Speaker:

spiel, um, of, you know, "People don't really remember you.

Speaker:

It's been a couple years, but, you know, the writers, they wanna do a

Speaker:

movie, you know, essentially you playing you." And he's like, "No." He basically

Speaker:

said, "No, I don't wanna do that." Um, and so the head of studio says,

Speaker:

"Well, then I don't have anything for you." And so he's kinda down and out.

Speaker:

Now, the actor who played Frank, Frank Capra- Mm.

Speaker:

That's great … I thought he was phenomenal.

Speaker:

Um, and part of that is it's, it's tough to be an actor playing off,

Speaker:

you know, a- playing someone who's as famous as Jimmy Stewart was.

Speaker:

Frank Capra, I mean, I don't know what he sounds like, what he, what

Speaker:

he, what his mannerisms were, but I thought the way his, the actor

Speaker:

portraying him, um, characterized him in the movie with Jimmy Stewart and

Speaker:

that relationship was just phenomenal.

Speaker:

And so that's the next thing, and we kinda, we talked, we joked about this,

Speaker:

where Frank Capra, he's sitting down with Jimmy Stewart not long after

Speaker:

he's come back, and he's trying to kinda get him back into a movie, and

Speaker:

he's telling him about this script.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

About a guy who wants to commit suicide, but an angel comes down and stops him.

Speaker:

And he's like, "Oh, is his name Gabriel?" And he goes, "No, Clarence." Yeah.

Speaker:

Um, and but the funny thing is, and w- you and I commented on this, and

Speaker:

this is like a nod to Frank Capra's short-lived production company.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

Um, they put this sign that said Liberty up behind them, and they

Speaker:

had one half up, and, and these two, and these two kinda side characters

Speaker:

are putting the other half up.

Speaker:

And that was true.

Speaker:

That was… Was it Liberty, Liberty Fil- It was Pi- yeah, Pictures.

Speaker:

Liberty Pictures.

Speaker:

And, and you'll see it in the beginning of It's a Wonderful Life.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

It's the Liberty Bell, and it says Liberty Pictures.

Speaker:

That's the only movie they ever made.

Speaker:

But a- and then, and then later after the movie, you know, and this isn't a

Speaker:

spoiler, but, but a- after the movie comes out, it wasn't really a hit.

Speaker:

It was kind of a, a s- little bit of a flop at the time.

Speaker:

Um, and so they're sitting in the same room, and the two guy- the two,

Speaker:

same two guys are coming, and they, they take down the Liberty, the

Speaker:

Liberty, uh, sign in the background.

Speaker:

And it's kind of just a, a joke, a nod to the short-lived production

Speaker:

company that Frank Capra started.

Speaker:

But he talks to him about this, about It's a Wonderful Life.

Speaker:

So Frank Capra and Jimmy Stewart already have a relationship.

Speaker:

They did Mr. Smith Goes to Washington together, right?

Speaker:

They've done some pretty big movies that, uh, have captured America,

Speaker:

and so they know each other.

Speaker:

But Frank Capra also served at the time.

Speaker:

He made war movies, and so that's why he's wearing his uniform.

Speaker:

And you see him with Jimmy Stewart a couple times through

Speaker:

the movie, just kinda catching up.

Speaker:

Now, when Jimmy Stewart comes home from the war, he doesn't know if he

Speaker:

can act anymore because a lot of his acting was just this, uh, novice guy

Speaker:

who's bu- you know, bumbling through life and just figuring stuff out.

Speaker:

An, an innocent man.

Speaker:

An inno- and he doesn't know if he can do that.

Speaker:

He actually thinks about running the family store, going back

Speaker:

and running the family store.

Speaker:

Um, his former agent, uh, had already left the talent business.

Speaker:

He's, his contract to MGM has been sold, and that's why he's able to work

Speaker:

with Frank Capra on his new movie.

Speaker:

And because he knows Frank Capra and Frank Capra was like, "I'd like to do

Speaker:

this with you," he gives it a, a try.

Speaker:

And, um- But it's d- it's during the filming he experiences doubts

Speaker:

with his abilities, and he's like, "Maybe I'm not ready for this." Not

Speaker:

to the extent they show in the movie.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

The, the movie, they, they focus on a couple of very emotional scenes, right?

Speaker:

The… if, and if you've ever seen It's a Wonderful Life, like, when he comes

Speaker:

home, um, and he's lost the money, right?

Speaker:

And he comes home to his, his wife and kids, and he's kicking

Speaker:

things, and he's just all upset.

Speaker:

Um, but the one scene that they… I, I think they nailed, that they

Speaker:

absolutely nailed, was him sitting at, at the bar kind of praying to God.

Speaker:

He's at his wit's end.

Speaker:

He's at his wit's end, and what they show in the, what they show

Speaker:

in the movie is that he, he's just having a hard time with the acting.

Speaker:

And then so Frank Capra clears the set- And kind of comes up to him, right?

Speaker:

And kind of really kind of draws him out.

Speaker:

He's like, "Just kind of be you.

Speaker:

Like speak from that- Mm-hmm … place in, in your heart," right?

Speaker:

And then he, he gives this performance.

Speaker:

And, and the reality of it is, I, I did look this up, so that PTSD, that, that

Speaker:

trauma kind of really shown through in that moment when he's praying to God.

Speaker:

It was one of those things, it really was a kind of a shock to Frank

Speaker:

Capra and those that were filming.

Speaker:

It says right here, um, "It's a Wonderful Life, his breakdown during the bar

Speaker:

prayer scene was completely unscripted. Stewart tapped into a real wartime grief,

Speaker:

catching Frank Capra so off-guard that Capra had to optically enlarge the film

Speaker:

frame in post-production." I don't think they were even ready- To get a close

Speaker:

with, with, with the framing and to kind of get the close-up

Speaker:

and everything like that.

Speaker:

And, and they joke about that in the movie.

Speaker:

Like, "You don't want the close-up?" And he was like, "No," because he had just

Speaker:

done this like truly- Cried … he cried in this true, true emotional, um, scene.

Speaker:

And so that's why he optically enlarged it.

Speaker:

He's like, "Okay, we won't try to do that again," right?

Speaker:

It was, it was… They, they had done a couple takes.

Speaker:

He got this out of him.

Speaker:

So a- and he was like, "Well, let's do it again," and Jimmy was like, "No, I

Speaker:

can't do that again." And I think in the movie, they use h- his fictional crew who

Speaker:

he lost when he wasn't flying with them, as they're coming back and watching him.

Speaker:

'Cause I think in the movie they want to make it very apparent for you- Yeah

Speaker:

… what he's processing in that moment.

Speaker:

Uh, and so it, it probably is all lends itself to PTSD that he comes

Speaker:

back from war and he's making this movie again about this person who is

Speaker:

out there with Ann, and he can really tap into the people who never got

Speaker:

to come back and live their lives.

Speaker:

And because you can't really just do the blanket statement of that in a movie,

Speaker:

they want to show you the real connection- Yeah … is why they had the crew and that

Speaker:

connection, even though that wasn't real.

Speaker:

So when people ask, uh, "Did his crew die? Did he run into the plane? Did he…" No.

Speaker:

That, none of that was reality.

Speaker:

He lost crews as the deputy colonel or c- commander and as the commander.

Speaker:

He would lose crews, but they weren't his personal crews, and he wasn't

Speaker:

in the cockpits when they passed.

Speaker:

But again, movie really wants it to make it very clear for you what's happening.

Speaker:

Uh, but What's, what's great about that is, uh, it was both Capra and,

Speaker:

uh, Stewart's first film after the war.

Speaker:

And so it really is this movie of, you know, hope, and

Speaker:

that's why I love it so much.

Speaker:

It's just the most uplifting, best movie about your ordinary life could be so

Speaker:

impactful to the world, to so many people.

Speaker:

And, uh, and then at the end, you know, no man's a failure who has friends.

Speaker:

But unfortunately, Capra's production company does fail- Yeah

Speaker:

because the movie is not a hit.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

The, the, the movie's a little bit of a flop at the time.

Speaker:

It doesn't really become more popular till later when, when people start

Speaker:

watching it essentially every Christmas.

Speaker:

Um, but one of the things that, that is accurate is his marriage

Speaker:

just not long after there.

Speaker:

Yeah, so right after that he will meet Gloria, and he doesn't, uh,

Speaker:

meet her on the beach, but that was a really great way to show it.

Speaker:

He meets her at, uh, a blind date, actually I think at

Speaker:

the Henry Fonda's house.

Speaker:

Um, but she has two boys from a first marriage, and they will marry, and

Speaker:

they will have twin daughters of their own, and they stay married for her

Speaker:

entire life and, and for his as well.

Speaker:

And actually, his last words before he dies is, "I'm

Speaker:

gonna go be with Gloria now."

Speaker:

And so when I visited his grave, he's buried beside his wife Gloria, and

Speaker:

his adopted son was killed in Vietnam.

Speaker:

And so he w- He's also buried there beside them.

Speaker:

And, uh, it was great to visit all three of them while I was there.

Speaker:

Uh, and Jimmy Stewart will rise through the ranks, and he will

Speaker:

become a brigadier general, and he stays in the Army Reserves.

Speaker:

And what's great about the museum is they have his office there, so you

Speaker:

can see what his office looked like as a military brigadier general.

Speaker:

Uh, but that will make him the highest ranking actor of all time.

Speaker:

And in his lifetime- He never wanted to draw attention to that.

Speaker:

He was most proud of It's a Wonderful Life when it came to the movies he made,

Speaker:

but by far, he was more proud of his military career than his acting career.

Speaker:

But he never wanted to draw attention to that.

Speaker:

He never wanted to capitalize on that, and I think this movie

Speaker:

does a good job of giving him credit for that, where he never-

Speaker:

Yeah … really got it in his lifetime.

Speaker:

And so that's what I really appreciate about this movie is a lot of times when

Speaker:

we would make videos about Jimmy Stewart or talk about Jimmy Stewart, I would say

Speaker:

the highest ranking actor of all time, and people would be like, "Really?"

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So it was something that wasn't known, and I'm really proud that

Speaker:

this movie makes it very clear.

Speaker:

Yeah, and, and the fact that he continued his service, right?

Speaker:

He, I mean, he flew, and he was still in command, like, during Vietnam, right?

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

And, and so a- and there was, there was points, you know, they wanted

Speaker:

to use, I think, his last flight.

Speaker:

One of the last flight he did was during Vietnam, and they want- In February of

Speaker:

1966 … and they wanted to use it kinda as, like, a promotional propaganda type

Speaker:

thing, and he wouldn't let them do it.

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

And he served for 27 years.

Speaker:

He officially retired from the Air Force March 31st, 1968.

Speaker:

He reached the mandatory retirement age of 60.

Speaker:

So yes, and so he, his last flight, he did an a, a non-duty observer in a B-52.

Speaker:

But, uh, yeah, he made, uh, brigadier general, and so it's

Speaker:

really great to honor him for that.

Speaker:

What I also liked is during the Academy Awards during the war, he would wear

Speaker:

his uniform to the Academy Awards, and I always thought that was the coolest thing.

Speaker:

Uh, nowadays you'd be hard-pressed to even know any actor-

Speaker:

Yeah … who's active duty.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

He, his movies are considered some of the greatest movies of all time.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

He's considered… He's always on the top five list of best actors of all

Speaker:

time, and it's like he's not even acting sometimes when you see him in roles.

Speaker:

He's just playing… He's, he is that person, and I think his wartime

Speaker:

experience took him from that man in A Philadelphia Story to the man

Speaker:

we see in It's a Wonderful Life to what we see in Rear Window to we see

Speaker:

in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.

Speaker:

And his acting career will last… I mean, we just watched him

Speaker:

in North and South last night.

Speaker:

Yeah, that was 1986.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

It lasts just the rest of his life.

Speaker:

So he is someone to be celebrated.

Speaker:

I will say the actor- was good, and I, he gave it his best shot.

Speaker:

But, uh, Jimmy Stewart is a hard person to capture.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Because he's just so individual and, and it makes it look so easy on screen.

Speaker:

I do appreciate the actor who played him, though.

Speaker:

They tried to do the, the, the, the voice and the talk and how he looked.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

If, if you're a Jimmy Stewart film fan, I think you'll enjoy this movie.

Speaker:

If, if you're not familiar with, as, as familiar with Jimmy Stewart, but

Speaker:

you're curious, I still think that you would enjoy it because there's,

Speaker:

there's… They don't focus a lot on the historical kind of, uh, wartime stuff.

Speaker:

It's really about him.

Speaker:

It really focuses on him.

Speaker:

It's not he did this operation, that operation.

Speaker:

It's really about him and his experience and, and him as an

Speaker:

actor and, and through his life.

Speaker:

Um, but I would recommend it.

Speaker:

You know, it was fun.

Speaker:

It was fun to go see.

Speaker:

Um, I wouldn't call it, uh, an amazing, like, phenomenal m- m- movie.

Speaker:

You know, I've seen other biopics that I probably like a little bit more,

Speaker:

but it's really fun to see someone who's such a favorite actor of ours.

Speaker:

Um, a- and I would… If you're a Jimmy Stewart fan, I, I would,

Speaker:

I would give it a thumbs up.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I definitely would give it a thumbs up.

Speaker:

It got long in some places, like I said.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And a lot of it's not accurate, but they're trying to give you

Speaker:

the story of Jimmy Stewart.

Speaker:

Uh, but I really appreciated the little nods to It's a Wonderful

Speaker:

Life, my favorite movie of all time.

Speaker:

And, uh, because we love Jimmy Stewart on this channel, we really

Speaker:

loved seeing this movie, and we definitely recommend seeing it, but,

Speaker:

uh, just know that it's not perfect.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And if you've seen it, let us know what you think.

Speaker:

You know, I'd be curious to hear your guys' thoughts on the movie.

Speaker:

As the theater lights come back up and you step outside into the

Speaker:

night air, you realize that Jimmy Stewart's greatest performance wasn't

Speaker:

captured on a Hollywood sound stage.

Speaker:

It was lived out in the cockpit of a B-24 over Europe.

Speaker:

He didn't have to go.

Speaker:

He had every excuse to stay safe, collect his paychecks, and

Speaker:

let someone else fight the war.

Speaker:

Instead, he showed up, put on the uniform, and carried the weight of

Speaker:

command and loss right alongside millions of ordinary Americans.

Speaker:

When he came home, he brought that quiet, hard-earned humanity back to the screen,

Speaker:

giving us moments in It's a Wonderful Life that still break our hearts and

Speaker:

lift our spirits 80-plus years later.

Speaker:

The new film Jimmy reminds us that the real hero wasn't just the character

Speaker:

he played, it was the man himself.

Speaker:

We'll talk to you next time.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

This has been a Walk With History production.

Speaker:

Talk With History is created and hosted by me, Scott Benne.

Speaker:

Episode researched by Jennifer Benne.

Speaker:

Check out the show notes for links and references mentioned in this episode.

Speaker:

Make sure you hit that follow button in that podcast player,

Speaker:

and we'll talk to you next time

Supporters

☕️ Help keep us caffeinated!
Support the show
L
Larry Myers $25
Keep doing what you two are doing. Nobody does it better
C
Calvin G. $5
Love both of your channels!
P
Pamela $20
Love your show! Currently listening to the Colonial Williamsburg episode, lived in Richmond in the 1990s many happy memories in Williamsburg. 5 stars
S
Stephanie Barnes $10
I spend lots of time in the car with my kids, and we all love listening :)
L
Larry Z $25
Caught with every podcast. Discovered after learning about them through Pin-Ups For Vets when Jenn became an ambassador. WW II content my favorite.
J
Jack B $5
Thank you for the great podcasts and for sharing your passion! Love hearing about the locations you visit.
Show artwork for Talk With History | History Travel & Road Trips

About the Podcast

Talk With History | History Travel & Road Trips
We're the history podcast that helps you travel to the history.
One filmmaker, one historian (and former Navy pilot), and your next historic road trip.

We give you the history you can visit. 🧳

Scott and Jenn combine deep historical storytelling with real-world travel, taking you behind the scenes of battlefields, historic sites, museums, famous graves, hidden landmarks, and the people and events that shaped America.

Every episode answers three questions:
What happened here? Why does it matter? And how can you experience it yourself?

🎙️Listen to the history, 🔎 discover the location, and 🗺️ plan your next historic adventure.

What you’ll get every episode:
🔎 The Inside Scoop: Deep-dive stories from historians, authors, or local guides.
📍 Travel-Ready Insights: Practical context to brush up on history before your next trip.
📝 Interactive Show Notes: Packed with direct map links, video resources, and site guides so you can build your own itinerary.

✓ Whether you're planning your next vacation or exploring from your couch, hit Follow or Subscribe now to start your next history adventure!
Support This Show

About your hosts

Scott B

Profile picture for Scott B
Host of the Talk With History podcast, Producer over at Walk with History on YouTube, and Editor of TheHistoryRoadTrip.com

Jennifer B

Profile picture for Jennifer B
Former Naval Aviator turned Historian and a loyal Penn Stater. (WE ARE!) I earned my Masters in American History and graduate certificate in Museum Studies, from the University of Memphis.

The Talk with History podcast gives Scott and me a chance to go deeper into the details of our Walk with History YouTube videos and gives you a behind-the-scenes look at our history-inspired adventures.

Join us as we talk about these real-world historic locations and learn about the events that continue to impact you today!